top of page

ICE CREAM PIES

Gelati Celesti Ice Cream_Turtle Ice Cream Pie_4.jpg

It's always pie time.

A cool twist on traditional classics, signature pies are celebration-ready and waiting. Choose from our House Favorites available for immediate pickup or online purchase or let us craft a custom pie that's uniquely yours.

HOUSE FAVORITES

Slice into happiness with one of our five always-available ice cream pies! Order online or stop by to grab and go.

CUSTOM-MADE

You pick the perfect flavor duo, and we'll layer them into the perfect handcrafted pie - no special occasion needed!

Gelati Celesti Ice Cream_Chocolate Peanut Butter Ice Cream Pie_4.jpg

chocolate peanut butter pie

Rich Chocolate Peanut Butter ice cream—and peanut butter and fudge icing—all in one delicious bite.

Contains: Milk, Wheat, Soy, Peanut
​
Always available for online or in-store pick up. 

Cakes & Pies not available at our Red Mill shop.

ORDER ONLINE
Gelati Celesti Ice Cream_Mud Pie Ice Cream Pie_2.jpg

mud pie

Creamy Coffee & Cream Ice Cream, a generous serving of chocolate chunks, and ribbons of thick fudge. What’s not to love?

Contains: Milk, Wheat, Soy
​
Always available for online or in-store pick up. 

Cakes & Pies not available at our Red Mill shop. 

ORDER ONLINE
Gelati Celesti Ice Cream_Cookies and Cream Ice Cream Pie Slice_1.jpg

cookies & cream

Thick, creamy, filled with our Cookies & Cream Ice Cream, made with crushed OREO® Cookies with even more cookie chunks stirred in for double the flavor.

Contains: Milk, Wheat, Soy
​
Always available for online or in-store pick up. 

Cakes & Pies not available at our Red Mill shop.

ORDER ONLINE
Gelati Celesti Ice Cream_Birthday Cake Ice Cream Pie_2.jpg

birthday cake

Perfect for birthdays or just because days. Our festive Birthday Cake Ice Cream is transformed into pie form and ready to join any party.

Contains: Milk, Wheat, Soy
​
Always available for online or in-store pick up. 

Cakes & Pies not available at our Red Mill shop.

ORDER ONLINE
Gelati Celesti Ice Cream_Turtle Ice Cream Pie_3.jpg

turtle

So much deliciousness in one pie. Graham cracker crust, Vanilla Ice Cream, caramel sauce, pecans, and chocolate fudge icing.

Contains: Milk, Wheat, Soy, Tree Nut - Pecan
​
Always available for online or in-store pick up. 

Cakes & Pies not available at our Red Mill shop.

ORDER ONLINE
bottom of page